First of all, the narrative structure is very different. Frequently, the plot of Jane Eyre is compared to Beauty and the Beast, but that characterization could apply to W. I will admit the truth: Emily Bronte wrote Wuthering Heights from the opposite view. Catherine is the one who obtains a more graceful and acceptable social standing where as Heathcliff is seen as the unwanted brute who would not obtain any form of wealth and stability in life.
So in a way it makes sense that heroies would be painted in broad strokes so that it is easier for more women to identify. They broke all the rules and principles that were so carefully sketched out in society. Women also did not have the right to obtain a divorce.
Heathcliff was in love with the good and the bad that came along with Cathy.
When Lizzy agreed to marry Mr. Austen clung to her roots and wrote a story of the time period, where rules and regulations ruled the land, and legitimacy is what mattered most.
It is seen as strong, even over-bearing, and something that cannot be lived without. Pride and Prejudice is a more typical love story man meets woman, complications arise, man gets womanwhile Wuthering Heights deals with the deeply passionate but tragic love between Catherine and Heathcliff.
Though the two differ, both couples end up realizing that regardless of social standing, they do in fact love each other. Lockwood sees the ghost of Catherine, and it is what pushes him to ask for explanations to Nelly, and then Nelly will tell him the story of the two lovers. Wuthering Heights begins at present for them and then is told as a series of flashbacks, sometimes through letters, but with two different first-person narrators.
Love is definitely present and cannot be ignored, but it does not make any ruling decisions for the young couples in search of a spouse.
Heaven did not seem to be my home; and I broke my heart with weeping to come back to earth; and the angels were so angry that they flung me out into the middle of the heath on the top of Wuthering Heights; where I woke sobbing for joy.
Heathcliff could not bear the thought of living without Catherine in his life. Jane Austen wrote of a marriage that was lucky to find love amidst the social conventions that were so clearly followed.
During this time period women had absolutely nothing. In two straight lines… Catherine, of all three characters, values romance the most. Catherine has far less mental acuity than Jane or Elizabeth, and her decision-making feels far more flighty and unexpected.
It accepts the social norm of a marriage not based wholly on love. Bronte, on the other hand, wrote her novel with social evolution in thought. She believed in the soul and the heart above all other aspects.
That was the point.
I have read Wuthering Heights three times, all before the age of She wrote of an illegitimate marriage due to social constraints and the pain that accompanies that. In men were given the right to divorce their wives on the sole grounds of adultery.
Love overcame legitimacy in Wuthering Heights. Women were brought up to marry and reproduce. Pride and Prejudice vs Wuthering Heights We have so large base of authors that we can prepare a unique summary of any book.
Darcy and vice versa. It happened to just be a coincidence that the young couples fell in love. Lastly, both works, while NOT biographical, were influenced by the authors' lives.
She wrote the novel from a romantic standpoint and rejected the precepts of order, calm, harmony, balance, idealization, and rationality that typified Classicism.
She saw what was real.
The primary effect of these elements is the dark and gloomy mood of the story. Stubborn — Darcy and Heathcliff tie in a 1, Rochester comes in from behind at 2.
There was no sound option to do otherwise because marriage ensured stability and wealth. Stubborn — Darcy and Heathcliff tie in a 1, Rochester comes in from behind at 2. I will admit the truth: First of all, and I'm willing to bet money that few if any of your classmates will write about this the narrative structure is verry different.
Catherine told Nelly that she dreamt once that she was in heaven and that it was horrible and she did not belong. I read Wuthering Heights once, and at this point, I agree with you, not ready for that one again.
I just finished Pride and Prejudice for the first time.
I love – love — the A&E Version and dearly wish I had read the book first as it was a long assignment to get through it. Aug 06, · Just finished Wuthering Heights this week, absolutely loved it but it is so different to Pride and Prejudice I don't think you can really compare them.
Though I suppose the Cathy/Hareton part does have some parallels to Elizabeth Bennett/Mr Darcy. Pride and Prejudice is a more typical love story (man meets woman, complications arise, man gets woman), while Wuthering Heights deals with the deeply passionate but tragic love between Catherine and Heathcliff.
May 28, · Wuthering Heights seems to offer substance, while Pride and Prejudice seems, to me, just a superficial love story (this is my opinion, nothing more). WH is a story of true passion that crosses barriers and offers elleandrblog.com: Resolved. May 28, · Wuthering Heights seems to offer substance, while Pride and Prejudice seems, to me, just a superficial love story (this is my opinion, nothing more).
WH is a story of true passion that crosses barriers and offers elleandrblog.com: Resolved. Wuthering Heights, Jane Eyre and Pride and Prejudice Wuthering Heights presents the theme of love within and outside of marriage. This book has a major female character whose marriage conflicts in some way with her ideal of love.Pride and prejudice vs wuthering heights